For any adjudicator, panelists,4 Considerations In Creating Motions or evaluators of debates, there are some pretty strict guidelines to what should be debated. This not only includes the ethical and moral standards of an intellectual discourse but also other factors. Such as if it should be even debated about, what purpose should it serve,4 Considerations In Creating Motions etc.
Remember that in a debate, there are no right or wrong sides, there are only the government and the opposition sides. Wherein both sides (houses), are on equal footing with their motions and aim to propose a better solution compared to the other.
But no matter how good your debating team is, these are some considerations to what a motion should be for debates:
1) Timeliness and Era By Debates
There is no sense in debating something that already has a solution. And certain societal, economic, and other factors are contemporary. For example, the current context of the world has changed because of the pandemic. And as such many argue that there is no need for face masks even at the onset of the pandemic.
This idea seems to be a debatable topic, but this only applies from the point where the pandemic started onwards. This would not be a debatable idea 2 or 3 years ago. This is why time plays a crucial role in deciding debatable topics.
2) Relevance In Context For Debates
Relevance means everything in a debate, especially in arguments. One cannot simply hold a debate without the significance of the topic in terms of the current time. Though there are topics that still remain relevant today such as abortion, the death penalty, and same-sex marriage. But there are some topics that are debatable but don’t hold any significance in respect to the current time.
An example of this would be lowering the age of senior citizens to age 55 instead of 60. This is a debate topic, but given how the world goes, for now, it can be put to a postpone. Another factor to also consider is the place or context of the debate.
For example, in the Philippines, where same-sex marriage is not legal, this is a hot topic. But for its Asian counterparts such as Thailand, this won’t be a debatable topic anymore.
3) Level Of Difficulty
A common misconception among debaters is that they know everything. But of course, this is not the case. There are some topics that are really challenging to debate about. This is because resources are not available, there are also nearly impossible topics such as religion. So it is also important to consider the level of difficulty in deciding motions.
4) Educational Background
You can’t expect a history teacher to teach you math, or for a dentist to cure your cough. These are professions that have specializations, and even if they are generally called teachers, or doctors, they have a specialized field of knowledge.
This is true for motions of debate. You can’t make two teachers debate about something deeply rooted in medicine. Even though it can happen, let’s try to fit the shapes into the proper holes, as this gives also respect to their educational background and specialization.
There are a lot more factors to consider in making motions for debates. Critical thinking and open-mindedness as well as thinking on your feet are all relevant skills to debating.
If you want to participate in practice debates or want to get good at it, try out some Escape2Win Vigina Beach for some IQ boost! Also, try Clue IQ – A Maryland Escape Room Experience, for brain juice for you and your friends.
Debates are important as many issues are settled this way. This is like intellectual sparring, or brain practice that can solve issues, or offer better solutions.
People also read: Business Analytics Importance for Success